Capital market development and mass privatization are logical contradictions: lessons from Russia and the Czech Republic
نویسندگان
چکیده
The introduction of mass privatization policies in Russia and the Czech Republic depended on the creation of impersonal capital markets to finance the needs of privatized companies and to provide a secondary market for the trading of securities. Yet, mass privatization created the contradictory conditions of generating millions of poorly informed shareholders, with no efficient markets for the sale of the shares. The absence of financial markets created systematic pressures to move assets by illegal or non-transparent means to users who value them more. Privatization created the incentives to destroy the financial markets critical to its success. A comparative case analysis of post-privatization market formation in both these countries demonstrates that the functional necessity for these markets does not engender their own creation. In the absence of institutional mechanisms of state regulation and trust, markets become arenas for political contests and economic manipulation. The irony of these policies is that a principal lesson has been that market reforms cannot create viable markets, only institutional formation can.
منابع مشابه
Privatization Success and Failure: Finance Theory and Regulation in the Transitional Economies of Albania and the Czech Republic
This paper examines the transition of economies of Albania and the Czech Republic, noting that their relative failure and success could have been predicted by academic literature. Financial intermediation theory predicted the rise of independently created mutual funds in the Czech Republic, while similar intermediation literature related to monitoring (or the lack thereof) predicted the develop...
متن کاملInvestment Privatization Funds, Banks and Corporate Governance in the Czech Republic and Russia
متن کامل
Linking Housing and Capital Markets in the Former Soviet Bloc: The Status of Residential Mortgage Bond and Secondary Markets in the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and Russia
Since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the Russian Federation ("Russia") and former soviet satellite countries and republics of Central and Eastern Europe ("Soviet Bloc") have struggled with privatizing housing and establishing market-based residential mortgage systems. This thesis addresses the recent efforts of three former Soviet Bloc countries (the Czech Republic, Hungary and Polan...
متن کاملCapital Market Development in Russia
• issuance of 147,000,000 privatization checks (vouchers) as freely transferable bearer securities, accepted by the State as payment for shares of privatized enterprises (huge educational effect, redistribution of ownership and creation of the securities market); • massive transformation of state-owned enterprises into joint-stock companies and issue of shares of privatized enterprises; • vouch...
متن کاملA Privatization Test: The Czech Republic, Slovakia and Poland
The nations of the former Communist bloc face a task unparalleled in the annals of world history. By promoting allocation of market resources based on politics and social policy instead of economic efficiencies, the former regimes created economies of inefficiency. Committed economic reformers face the task of reallocating resources from inefficient producers dependent on government monies to c...
متن کامل